Click here for Home

  News
  updated 3/7/06

  Resources
     Free
     Premium

  Books/CDs

  Seminars

  Services

  Search

  About Us

  Contact Us

Click here for Home

Criminal Defense of Immigrants

Chapter 1: Criminal Defense of Noncitizens

Table of Contents

§ 1.1 I. Introduction

§ 1.2 A. Noncitizens Form a Surprising Proportion of the Population

§ 1.3 B. Effective Counsel Must Research and Take Immigration Consequences Into Account in Defending a Criminal Case

§ 1.4 C. Immigration Results of a Criminal Case Often Outweigh the Criminal Consequences

§ 1.5 D. Obtaining Expert Immigration Help

§ 1.6 II. Getting the Client out of Custody Pending Trial

§ 1.7 A. Dealing With Immigration Holds and Detainers

§ 1.8 B. Mandatory INS Detention

§ 1.9 III. The Basic Approach to Minimizing Immigration Effects

§ 1.10 IV. First Client Interview

§ 1.11 A. Preparation

§ 1.12 B. Basic Goals

§ 1.13 C. Determining U.S. Citizenship or Immigration Status

§ 1.14 D. Obtaining Immigration Facts

§ 1.15 E. Basic Immigration Status Questionnaire

§ 1.16 F. Obtaining Information on Client's Equities

§ 1.17 G. Obtaining Basic Criminal History

§ 1.18 H. Determining how Important the Immigration Consequences Are to the Client

§ 1.19 I. Advice not To Discuss Immigration Situation With Authorities

§ 1.20 V. Investigation of the Case From an Immigration Perspective

§ 1.21 A. In General

§ 1.22 B. The Timing of the Case

§ 1.23 C. Dealing With Bias Against Noncitizens

§ 1.24 VI. Results That Minimize Adverse Immigration Effects

§ 1.25 A. Diversion Programs

§ 1.26 B. Deferred Entry of Judgment Programs or Other Forms of State Rehabilitative Relief.

§ 1.27 C. Dismissal of Charges

§ 1.28 D. Sentencing Procedures To Minimize Adverse Immigration Consequences

§ 1.29 E. Pleading to a Different Offense That Does not Carry Immigration Consequences

§ 1.30 F. Taking the Case to Trial

§ 1.31 G. Post-Conviction Work

§ 1.32 VII. Plea Bargaining

§ 1.33 A. Some Common Immigration-Safe Pleas

§ 1.34 1. Controlled Substances Offenses

§ 1.35 2. Firearms Offenses

§ 1.36 3. Aggravated Felony Convictions

§ 1.37 4. Crimes of Moral Turpitude

§ 1.38 5. Domestic Violence Convictions and Violations of Protective Orders

§ 1.39 6. Miscellaneous Convictions

§ 1.40 B. Deciding Whether To Alert the Prosecution or Court to the Immigration Issues

§ 1.41 C. The Criminal Case With Major Immigration Effects

§ 1.42 D. Avoiding Admission of Crime-Related Factors Having Adverse Immigration Consequences Even Without a Conviction

§ 1.43 E. The Defense Negotiating Position

§ 1.44 F. The Search for Alternative Results That Minimize Immigration Consequences

§ 1.45 G. Dealing With Interpreters in Court

§ 1.46 1. The Right to an Interpreter in Criminal Proceedings

§ 1.47 2. Using an Interpreter in Court

§ 1.48 VIII. Entry of Plea

§ 1.49 A. General Immigration Advice for Criminal Defendants

§ 1.50 1. Criminal Charges Can Cause Your Deportation

§ 1.51 2. How Your Lawyer Can Try To Avoid Negative Immigration Consequences

§ 1.52 B. The Duty to Advise the Client of the Specific Immigration Consequences

§ 1.53 C. Unduly Pessimistic Immigration Predictions Can Do as Much Harm as Inaccurate Predictions That no Adverse Immigration Consequences Will Ensue

§ 1.54 D. Advice of Exact Immigration Consequences

§ 1.55 IX. Sentencing

§ 1.56 A. Immigration Consequences Of Sentence

§ 1.57 1. Definition of "Sentence Imposed"

§ 1.58 a. What Is Included in "Sentence Imposed"

§ 1.59 b. Commitment to a Juvenile Facility Does Not Qualify as a Sentence to Confinement

§ 1.60 2. Length of "Sentence Imposed"

§ 1.61 a. Aggravated Felonies Requiring One-Year "Sentence Imposed"

§ 1.62 b. Petty Offense Exception to Inadmissibility Requires Sentence Imposed of Six Months or Less Petty Offense Exception Generally

§ 1.63 c. A Noncitizen Becomes Inadmissible if Convicted of Two or More Offenses for Which the Aggregate Sentences to Confinement Totaled Five Years or More

§ 1.64 d. Mandatory Detention Is Triggered if a Noncitizen Is Deportable for One Conviction of a Crime of Moral Turpitude for Which a Sentence of One Year or More Has Been Imposed

§ 1.65 e. Restriction on Removal (Formerly Withholding of Deportation) Requires a Noncitizen to Avoid an Aggregate Sentence of Five Years or More for Aggravated Felony Conviction(s)

§ 1.66 f. A Conviction Is Considered a Misdemeanor, for Purposes of Adjustment of Status, if the State Designates It as a Misdemeanor and the Sentence Imposed Is One Year or Less, Even if the Maximum Sentence Is Greater

§ 1.67 3. Length of Actual Confinement

§ 1.68 a. To Be Eligible for the Former Waiver of Deportability under INA § 212(c), the Noncitizen Must Avoid Service of an Actual Aggregate Sentence of Five Years or More for Aggravated Felony Conviction(s)

§ 1.69 b. A Noncitizen Is Disqualified from Showing Good Moral Character if Actually Confined as a Result of Criminal Convictions for a Total of 180 Days or More

§ 1.70 c. Situations that Require Good Moral Character

§ 1.71 4. Naturalization May Not Be Granted if the Applicant Is Currently On Probation or Parole

§ 1.72 5. The Sentencing Judgment, Which Forms Part of the "Record of Conviction," Can Lead to Adverse Immigration Consequences

§ 1.73 6. Waiving Credit for Time Served in Order To Avoid a Sentence of a Certain Length

§ 1.74 7. Sentencing for Probation Violations

§ 1.75 8. Restriction on Removal

§ 1.76 B. Obtaining a Sentence That Will Enable Client To Qualify for Post-Conviction Relief

§ 1.77 C. "Judicial Removal Proceedings" in Federal Sentencing Court

§ 1.78 X. Early Release from Criminal Custody to be Removed

§ 1.79 A. Early Release to Removal

§ 1.80 B. Prisoner Transfer Treaties

§ 1.81 XI. Parting Advice to Client — INS Proceedings Following Service of State Sentence

§ 1.82 XII. Post-Conviction Relief

§ 1.83 A. The Last Chance

§ 1.84 B. Counsel's Duty To Cooperate With Successor Counsel

§ 1.85 C. Counsel Is not Exposed to Discipline on the Basis of a Simple Mistake Alone

§ 1.86 D. Considerations in Cooperating With Successor Counsel

§ 1.87 E. Attorney-Client and Work-Product Privileges

§ 1.88 XIII. Conclusion


©2005 Norton Tooby.
All rights reserved.

Home | News | Free Resources | Books/CDs | Seminars
Services
| Search | About Us | Contact Us
Copyright & Disclaimers Policy